Forcing Googlebot to Observe the Sabbath
Posted by Melanie Phung on Friday, November 10, 2006 at 1:18 pm
Just when it starts to seem like I haven’t learned anything interesting in a while, I come across a thread called “Cloaking for Religious Reasons.”
Is there ever a good reason to engage in cloaking for the purpose of fooling Google? Even if God insists?
Turns out no — the problem being discussed could better be solved a different way (The problem: having to take down an e-commerce site in observance of Sabbath but needing to avoid search engine spiders replacing the entire site in their indexes/indices with the store’s “we’re currently closed” page. The solution: returning 503 errors).
Now I finally understand why B&H Photo wouldn’t let me place orders on their site at various times in the past. Turns out it wasn’t random… it was Saturday!










I’m pretty sure this isn’t the normative “halachic” decision on this matter. But like any religion, there are pragmatic religious people, and people who go “further.”
This is the opinion I know:
http://aishel.wordpress.com/2006/08/29/jewish-websites-and-shabbos/
I did find the other opinion here:
http://www.aishdas.org/avodah/vol11/v11n077.shtml#14
… but I don’t think most modern orthodox people follow it.